Home/Mohel vs. Hospital Circumcision
A Guide for Families

Mohel vs. Hospital Circumcision

By Rabbi Zvi Spiegel, Certified Mohel

While doctors are trained to perform circumcisions as a medical procedure, a mohel specializes in circumcision and performs it regularly as both a religious and practical discipline.

Should I Choose a Mohel or a Doctor?

A traditional bris milah performed by an experienced mohel is typically completed much more quickly than a hospital circumcision, which often relies on clamps or devices that prolong the procedure. A mohel is also trained in the laws and traditions of brit milah, ensuring that the bris is performed according to Jewish law.

When medical concerns arise, I work closely with pediatricians and specialists and will never proceed unless it is safe to do so. For families seeking a kosher bris, involving a qualified mohel from the outset is usually the best way to ensure both the religious and practical aspects are properly addressed.

Hospital Circumcision and Bris Milah

For families seeking a kosher bris, a hospital circumcision is generally not the ideal option. In addition to not automatically fulfilling the religious requirements of brit milah, hospital circumcisions are often performed using clamps and devices that can significantly lengthen the procedure.

The traditional bris milah technique used by an experienced mohel is typically completed in seconds rather than minutes. Because the procedure is so brief, many families find that discomfort is minimized and that babies settle quickly once they are swaddled and comforted.

Whenever possible, I encourage families who desire a bris to consult with a mohel before scheduling a hospital circumcision. This helps ensure that both the halachic and practical aspects of the procedure are addressed from the outset.

If Your Son Was Already Circumcised in the Hospital

If your son has already been circumcised in a hospital, I am happy to discuss whether hatafas dam brit or another procedure may be necessary to establish a kosher bris according to Jewish law.

How Is Pain Managed?

Parents naturally want to ensure their baby is as comfortable as possible. The bris is performed efficiently and gently in a calm environment using accepted comfort measures and pain-management techniques. I am always happy to discuss the procedure in detail and address any concerns you may have before the bris.

Medical Conditions

Every child is unique. If your son has a medical concern or anatomical condition such as hypospadias, chordee or torsion, I will work together with your pediatrician and, when appropriate, a pediatric urologist to determine the safest and most appropriate approach, while addressing both medical and religious concerns.

Have a Question?

Rabbi Spiegel is happy to answer questions and help you plan your son's bris.